Overnight Cinnamon Rolls with Cream Cheese Frosting
May contain affiliate links. See our disclosure policy.
Soft, chewy Overnight Cinnamon Rolls will make you the rock star of Christmas morning. We like to eat them warm with plenty of cream cheese frosting!
Rediscovering a Love for Overnight Cinnamon Rolls
For about a decade of my life, I refused to eat cinnamon rolls. It all started with the stomach flu, as so many bad stories do. I was about 12 years old and was spending the night at my best friend’s house while my parents got away for the weekend.
It had been the most glorious day. We played and ate ourselves silly, indulging in two of our favorite treats: boxed macaroni and cheese and Cinnabons. Everything was going along swimmingly until the middle of the night, when I woke up with the worst stomach ache of my life. I will refrain from sharing the gory details, but let’s just say cinnamon rolls were effectively ruined for me that fateful night.
For the next few years, I always felt a tinge queasy when I smelled the chemical-tinged cinnamon scent of giant Cinnabon rolls being piped through the mall. The strong aversion eventually subsided, but by that point I had convinced myself I didn’t like cinnamon rolls. And just like that, an entire cinnamon swirl lacking decade passed.
In my early 20s, I rediscovered my love for cinnamon rolls, and I now consider that time of my life “the lost years.” Think of all the gooeyness I missed in those years! The last few months I’ve been trying to make up for lost time by testing out ALL the cinnamon roll recipes. Someone should come test my blood, because I’m pretty sure it’s just rivers of cinnamon and butter by now. I’ve tried a copycat Cinnabon recipe, the Pioneer Woman’s cinnamon rolls, and a few “best ever” recipes from cookbooks I own.
Fluffy, Chewy Cinnamon Rolls
Of course, the ultimate recipe ended up being in the most obvious place–an old Mennonite cookbook. The recipe intrigued me from the very start. First off, it was made with bread flour. I don’t know why I never thought to make cinnamon rolls with bread flour before, but it makes so much sense! Bread flour makes the rolls extra chewy and gives them that dreamy, pullable texture I was longing for.
The recipe also adds eggs, butter, and milk to the cinnamon roll dough. All of these ingredients help keep the dough nice and soft and also gives the dough a lot more flavor than a simple yeast, flour, and water roll.
The cookbook gave me a great place to start making my own cinnamon roll recipe, but, like most of my Amish and Mennonite cookbooks, it left out some key details, including the quantities and ingredients for the filling!
I eyeballed my first batch, and it was good but not quite right. Luckily, the second batch was exactly what I was looking for–fluffy, chewy rolls around a buttery brown sugar filling with plenty of spicy cinnamon flavor.
Cream Cheese Frosting for Overnight Cinnamon Rolls
No cinnamon roll is complete without frosting, and for me, it’s gotta be cream cheese. I like to keep my frosting on the thick side so it melts a bit into the cracks and crevices of the roll, but you still have a nice slather on top.
Make Ahead Cinnamon Rolls: A MUST
I know everyone’s taste in cinnamon rolls is different, but let me tell you why these check all of my boxes. They’re chewy and soft, but still have a nice brown exterior. They’re sweet, but not in a cloying, my fillings are begging for mercy kind of way. They have a whole lot of cinnamon flavor, and most importantly, I can make them the day before I want to bake them.
Let’s be honest, this was a must for me. There is no possible way this girl is getting up at 5 AM to make cinnamon rolls. I love you, family, but no. I will, however, make these at a reasonable hour the day before Christmas and then look like a rock star when I pull fresh cinnamon rolls out of the oven on Christmas morning.
You can thank me by making Christmas Morning Punch and doing all the dishes.
Large Batch Cinnamon Rolls
One last note about these rolls. They make A LOT. Approximately 2 dozen generously sized rolls. This is fantastic if you’re having everyone over for Christmas, but perhaps not so wonderful if you’re making rolls for your tiny family of 3.
Luckily, you can also freeze pans of cinnamon rolls to pull out whenever the craving hits. OR, you could become the best neighbor/coworker/customer ever and distribute pans to everyone you know. Either way, no one has ever thought having too many cinnamon rolls is a problem.
More Make Ahead Breakfast Recipes:
Need more make ahead breakfasts for Christmas morning? Try these:
- Overnight Breakfast Casserole with Bacon
- Breakfast Pull Apart Bread
- Overnight Pancake Casserole
- Apple Overnight French Toast Casserole
I developed this recipe in partnership with Ohio Eggs. You can see the original Overnight Cinnamon Rolls recipe on their site!
Overnight Cinnamon Rolls
Ingredients
For the rolls:
- 2 packages fast rise instant yeast
- 3/4 cup warm water (aim for 105 to 115 degrees)
- 2 Tablespoons sugar
- 2 cups whole milk
- 8 Tablespoons butter (1 stick)
- 4 eggs (beaten)
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 1/2 cup sugar
- 9 cups bread flour (plus more for sprinkling)
For the filling:
- 1 cup brown sugar
- 1/2 cup white sugar
- 3/4 cup unsalted butter, at room temperature (1 1/2 sticks, 12 Tablespoons )
- 3 1/2 Tablespoons cinnamon
For the frosting:
- 1/2 cup butter, at room temperature (1 stick, 8 tablespoons )
- 12 ounces cream cheese (at room temperature)
- 2 1/2 cups powdered sugar
- Splash heavy cream
- 2 teaspoons vanilla
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
Instructions
- Add the water to the bowl of an electric mixer then stir in the sugar and yeast. Allow the mixture to sit for 10-15 minutes while you prepare the milk. The mixture should foam up quite a bit. If it doesn't froth or foam, your yeast might be bad, and you'll want to start over.
- Meanwhile, heat the milk to just below boiling, then stir in the butter, allowing it to melt. Allow the mixture to cool to warm.
- Stir the beaten eggs into the yeast mixture. Pour the cooled milk mixture into the yeast mixture in a steady stream, whisking constantly. Whisk in the remaining 1/2 cup of sugar and the salt.
- Add half of the flour to the bowl, using a spatula or spoon to combine. Add the remaining flour (up to 8 cups) and stir, then switch to the dough hook and beat until well combined. Continue to beat with the dough hook until the dough is soft and springy, about 6 minutes. If the mixture is still very sticky, add up to another cup of flour to the dough. The dough should be tacky but shouldn't coat your finger when you touch it.
- Place the dough in a greased bowl, cover loosely with saran wrap, and place in a warm spot to rise for 40 minutes to an hour, or until doubled in size.
- Punch the dough down and turn it out onto a floured surface. Roll or press the dough out into a rectangle approximately 12 inches by 24 inches long. Pour the melted butter over top, spreading it evenly. In a small bowl, whisk together the sugars and cinnamon and then sprinkle that evenly over the top. Cut the rectangle in half so there are two 12 x 12 inch squares. Either roll each square into a tight log and then cut it into 12 slices using dental floss OR use a pizza cutter to slice the rectangle into 24 long strips, and roll each strip individually into a slice. Once the rolls are sliced, place them in a buttered dish, approximately 8 in a 9 x 13 inch pan or 6 in a 9 inch pie pan. Cover the rolls loosely with saran wrap. Refrigerate the rolls overnight, for 8-12 hours.
- In the morning, take the rolls out and allow them to rise in a warm place for 30-45 minutes, or until puffed.
- Preheat the oven to 350 degrees. Place the rolls in the oven and bake for 20 minutes, or until tops are golden and set. I recommend under baking just slightly so the rolls stay nice and soft.
To make the frosting:
- Combine the cream cheese and butter in the bowl of an electric mixer. Beat on high speed until smooth. Beat in the powdered sugar, cream, vanilla, and salt. If you're serving immediately, the rolls can be frosted while still warm. Otherwise, store them unfrosted, then frost and reheat the rolls for a few minutes before serving.
Notes
- You can substitute regular yeast for the fast rise yeast, but your baking time may increase by up to 40%.
- If you would rather bake the cinnamon rolls right away instead of leaving them to set overnight, follow the instructions through step 6, then instead of refrigerating, immediately set the rolls in a warm place to rise for 40 minutes. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees and bake for 20 minutes or until golden.
These are just too good to be true. Chewy, yeasty, and rich. The frosting is so deelish, I could eat it plain by the spoonfuls! It is not overly sweet and is the perfect finishing touch. It does take planning, to start them the night before, but it’s so worth the effort!
I’ve had this pinned for years and finally made them for New Year’s Day. It did not disappoint!
My daughter and her British boyfriend (they live in Scotland) are visiting for the holidays and made these Christmas eve, and baked them on Christmas morning. NO WORDS-absolutely amazing! I made the icing and bc I forgot to halve the recipe (as they did), I have lots leftover, oh well, guess they’ll have to make some for New Year’s day :)! Thank you for this wonderful recipe-what a treat!
Made these again this year for Christmas morning. Cut the amounts down for 8 large rolls. It was absolutely the most delicious breakfast roll I have ever had. They came out perfect, thanks to your great instructions. Don’t change a thing! Everyone should experience these rolls at least once in their lifetime.
So I FINALLY made time to make these wonderful cinnamon rolls. They take some planning ahead (which is not my strong suit) so they will have time to rise the evening before you plan to bake them. These beauties are worth every bit of work though. I followed you directions and they turned out perfect!!! The roll is yeasty and chewy. The cinnamon filling is delicious. The frosting is to die for. I could eat the frosting by the spoonfuls if I thought my husband wouldn’t see it. What a fabulous treat for Christmas morning. Thanks so much for teaching us how to make the best cinnamon rolls in the world.
These would be lovely baked in the stoneware pieces. And you’re correct–it’s rising 40-45 minutes and baking for 20 minutes. I went ahead an added numbers to the recipe so hopefully that makes things clearer! And your assumption was correct. If you’re not refrigerating overnight, you can simply allow the rolls to rise for the second time in the pans and bake immediately.
Hi there! Thanks for sharing some of your story here. I’ve always love Anne of Green Gables so it was delight to read a little bit about your Memaw and PapPap’s love story. My dad was the youngest of 14 children in a Mennonite family, so I was spoiled with lots of hearty home cooking when I was growing up. I have several Amish and Mennonite cookbooks, and I’ve actually seen the recipe for dandelion salad before, but never made it. I will have to try it this year. To your questions: I haven’t tried making these in half sheet pans. My only concern about it would be if they puffed over the edges too much, but I think if the pans had at least a 1/2 inch lip around the outsides it would work. I also haven’t made these gluten free before. I know a little bit of your struggle, because my mom has had to follow a gluten free diet for the last 10 years. It can be really difficult! We’ve found using Cup for Cup gluten free flour usually works pretty well, but unfortunately we haven’t experimented with the substitute on this recipe yet. I do have a lot of other gluten free recipes on the site. If you’d like to check them out, you can find them here: https://neighborfoodblog.com/category/recipes-2/special-diets/gluten-free. Best of luck! Please let me know if you try these gluten free and how they turn out!
Bread flour for cinnamon rolls??? It never occurred to me but I’ll be trying it later. Are the amounts the same~cup for cup between A.P./bread flour? I want to use Ree’s recipe, too. Thanksabunch for the tip!!!! ~Judy
Generally, you can sub. cup for cup in bread recipes. I really like the chew that bread flour gives to the cinnamon rolls!
Can the rolls be frozen after Baking.? They look wonderful but make a lot for a small family.
I usually freeze mine before baking, then leave in the fridge overnight and let rise for 45 minutes or so in the morning before baking. I think you could freeze them baked too though!
I Want the recipe for home made dried apples pies.
Hi Mattie! Sorry for the delayed response. I think you’re looking for this recipe: https://neighborfoodblog.com/2014/10/amish-apple-fry-pie-recipe.html
Recipe amounts for these overnight cinnamon rolls seem off…way to much flour?? butter says 1/2 cup then in parentheses…(1 stick , 8 tablespoons….) that’s 2 cups! Cook time 3 hours? needs to have adjustments!
Hi Laura,
The flour is the correct amount. This makes a big batch of rolls! The butter is also correct. The amount in parenthesis is just to give equivalents (so 1/2 cup is equal to 8 Tablespoons or 1 stick). The total cook time at the top at 3 hours is off. Thanks for catching that! However, in the recipe you’ll see it says to bake for 35-45 minutes. The recipe has been made and loved by many people. I hope you’ll give it a try!
Great photos ! Great dish: never too much of cinnamon 🙂 Thank you and have a nice day !
Could this recipe be cut in half? Making this many for a family of 2 is just too many.
Absolutely. In fact, a friend of mine already cut it down to just make 4 large cinnamon rolls (This is sizing the recipe down by a quarter instead of half, but feel free to halve the measurements above if you’d like 8 rolls) Here are the measurements my friend used for the dough:
1 1/4 teaspoon instant yeast
1/4 cup water
1 teaspoon sugar
1/2 cup whole milk
2 tablespoons unsalted butter
2 eggs
2 tablespoons sugar
2 1/4 cup bread flour, plus more for kneading
For the filling, you can eyeball it, but it will be about 1/4 cup brown sugar, a few Tablespoons white sugar, 1/2 stick butter, and scant Tablespoon cinnamon.
Hope this helps!
Another bready carby goodness recipe of yours that I have to try ASAP! I mean, we’re having your butterhorns for Christmas Eve dinner so these would be perfect the next day!
I hope you loved these Melanie! You can just call me the carb queen from here on out. 🙂
My Screen suddenly developed smella vision scrolling down over this post.